What it means
Most commercial contracts now contain a dispute resolution clause that sets out what happens when the parties fall out. That clause typically requires negotiation first, then mediation, and only then arbitration or court proceedings.
Getting this wording right at signing costs almost nothing, while getting it wrong can cost a great deal later. Mediation and arbitration differ in one important way.
A mediator has no power to impose an outcome and simply helps the parties find a deal they can both live with, whereas an arbitrator issues a binding decision that courts will generally enforce. Mediation therefore preserves relationships better, while arbitration provides certainty of an ending.
The financial case for ADR is straightforward. Court proceedings involve extensive document disclosure, expert reports, barristers and often years of delay, and the legal spend can easily exceed the amount in dispute.
A mediation that concludes in a single day rarely costs more than a small fraction of that. There are real costs to the choice as well.
Arbitration awards are very difficult to appeal, so a poor decision usually stands, and the parties pay the arbitrator's fees themselves rather than using a publicly funded court. Confidentiality also cuts both ways, because a company that wants a public vindication will not get one from a private process.
Finance teams should care about ADR because it changes how disputes appear in the accounts. A contested claim heading to a multi-year trial may require a provision and a disclosure note, whereas a matter scheduled for mediation next month can often be resolved before the accounts are finalised.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
A construction firm and a property developer disagree over $1,200,000 of variation claims on a completed hotel. Rather than litigate, they appoint an independent quantity surveyor as adjudicator, receive a decision within twenty-eight days, and both continue bidding for work together the following year.
Example
A logistics company and its warehouse landlord dispute a service charge increase. A half-day mediation produces a compromise: the increase is halved for two years in exchange for the tenant extending the lease, an outcome no court could have ordered.
Example
A cross-border supply agreement between a US buyer and an Asian manufacturer specifies arbitration in a neutral seat under recognised institutional rules. When a quality dispute arises, neither side has to litigate in the other's home courts, and the award is enforceable in both countries.
Formula
Calculation
Cost saving from ADR = Estimated litigation cost - Estimated ADR cost
A software supplier is in dispute with a customer over $600,000 of unpaid licence fees. Its solicitors estimate that taking the claim to trial would cost $400,000 in legal fees, expert evidence and internal management time over roughly two years. A one-day commercial mediation, including the mediator's fee, venue, and legal preparation, is quoted at $60,000.
Cost saving from ADR = $400,000 - $60,000 = $340,000
As a percentage, ($340,000 / $400,000) x 100 = 85% of the expected dispute cost is avoided. Even if mediation fails and the case later proceeds to trial, the supplier has spent $60,000 for a realistic chance of saving $340,000, which is why most boards approve mediation before authorising litigation.Case study
Seen in the real world.
This is an illustrative, fictional scenario. Bramwell Packaging signed a three-year supply contract with Northgate Foods, then suffered a machinery failure that left four consecutive deliveries short. Northgate withheld $480,000 of payments and threatened to sue for the cost of buying replacement stock at short notice.
The contract required mediation before either party could issue proceedings. At the mediation, it emerged that Northgate's real concern was not the money but security of supply for the coming Christmas season. The parties agreed that Bramwell would credit $180,000, commit to a backup production line, and accept a service level clause with clear penalties.
The whole matter closed in eleven weeks for around $55,000 of combined costs. Bramwell's finance director later noted that a litigated version of the same dispute would have run past two year-ends, required a provision in both sets of accounts, and almost certainly ended the customer relationship.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Treating mediation as a sign of weakness. Proposing mediation is standard commercial practice, and in many jurisdictions unreasonably refusing it can be penalised in any later costs award.
- Copying a dispute clause from an old contract without checking it. Clauses that name the wrong institution, an unclear seat or a non-existent set of rules cause expensive arguments about process before anyone discusses the actual dispute.
- Sending someone to mediation without authority to settle. If the person in the room has to phone head office for approval of every figure, the day usually ends without agreement.
Questions
People also ask.
Is an arbitration award as enforceable as a court judgment?
Generally yes, and international awards are often easier to enforce across borders than a foreign court judgment thanks to widely adopted enforcement treaties.
Can we still go to court if mediation fails?
Yes in almost every case, because mediation is voluntary in outcome; only a binding arbitration clause genuinely removes the option of a trial.
Does ADR work when one side simply refuses to pay?
Less well, since ADR needs some willingness to engage; where a debtor is simply insolvent or evasive, formal recovery action is usually the more sensible route.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%Related