What it means
An insurance policy is a promise to pay when a defined event happens, and the law treats that promise as carrying a duty of good faith on both sides. When the insurer breaks that duty, the policyholder can sue not only for the money owed but for the harm caused by the refusal or delay.
That second claim is what people mean by bad faith. The distinction matters commercially because the policy limit stops being the ceiling.
A wrongly denied $400,000 claim is a $400,000 problem; a bad faith finding on the same file can produce consequential and punitive damages several times larger. This is exactly why claims departments follow documented investigation procedures.
Typical triggers include refusing to investigate, misrepresenting the policy wording, ignoring a reasonable settlement offer inside the limit, and unexplained delay. First-party bad faith arises when an insurer mistreats its own policyholder, while third-party bad faith arises when it exposes the policyholder to an excess judgment by refusing to settle a claim brought against them.
Rules vary widely by jurisdiction, and some places allow contract damages only. For a business buying cover, the practical lesson is to document everything: the date of notification, every request for information, and every response received.
A clean paper trail is what turns a slow claim into a provable one. For a business selling cover, the lesson is that a cheap denial can become the most expensive decision in the file.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
A haulage firm is sued after a collision and the claimant offers to settle within the $750,000 policy limit. The insurer refuses and the case goes to trial, where the jury awards $2,400,000. The excess of $2,400,000 - $750,000 = $1,650,000 becomes the subject of a third-party bad faith claim by the haulier against its own insurer.
Example
A boutique hotel files a storm damage claim and receives no adjuster visit for four months, followed by a denial citing a wear-and-tear exclusion the insurer never inspected for. The hotel's lawyer requests the claim file and finds no engineering report at all. The insurer settles quickly once the missing investigation becomes obvious.
Example
A specialist manufacturer's business interruption claim is met with repeated requests for documents it has already supplied three times. The pattern of recycled requests, logged in a simple dated spreadsheet, later becomes the core evidence that the delay was tactical rather than genuine.
Formula
Calculation
Bad faith exposure = unpaid policy benefit + interest on the delay + consequential damages + punitive damages
A fire damages a restaurant and the insurer withholds a valid $400,000 property claim for 18 months without a documented investigation.
Interest at a statutory 10% simple rate: $400,000 x 0.10 x 1.5 years = $60,000
Consequential damages, being trading profit lost while the premises stayed closed: $150,000
Compensatory subtotal: $400,000 + $60,000 + $150,000 = $610,000
Punitive damages assessed at twice the compensatory figure: $610,000 x 2 = $1,220,000
Total exposure: $610,000 + $1,220,000 = $1,830,000
The insurer saved $400,000 by refusing to pay and finished with a bill more than four times that size, before its own legal costs.Case study
Seen in the real world.
Kettle Row Ceramics is an invented company used for illustrative purposes. In this fictional scenario a kiln fire destroyed roughly half the firm's production capacity, and it notified its property and business interruption insurer the same week. The insurer acknowledged the claim, then went quiet for five months.
When the denial finally arrived it rested on a late notification argument, despite the acknowledgement letter in the file confirming notice within seven days. By that point Kettle Row had lost two long-standing wholesale accounts because it could not fulfil orders, and the owners had funded a replacement kiln from personal savings.
The illustrative point is not the size of the eventual settlement but the shape of the file: an acknowledgement that contradicted the denial, no adjuster report, and five months of silence. Those three facts made the insurer's position indefensible long before any court had to weigh the loss itself.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Assuming any denied claim is bad faith. Insurers are entitled to deny claims they have properly investigated and that genuinely fall outside the cover.
- Thinking the policy limit caps what the insurer can be made to pay. Bad faith damages sit outside the limit, which is the whole point of the doctrine.
- Chasing the insurer only by phone. Verbal chasing leaves no record, and a bad faith case is built almost entirely on dated written evidence.
Questions
People also ask.
What is the difference between bad faith and simple breach of contract?
Breach of contract is failing to pay what is owed, while bad faith is the unfair conduct surrounding that failure, and it opens the door to damages beyond the contract.
Do businesses have the same protection as consumers?
Broadly yes, though several jurisdictions apply a tougher standard to commercial policyholders on the assumption they had bargaining power.
How can a policyholder reduce the risk of unfair handling?
Notify in writing immediately, keep a dated log of every contact, and ask for the reason for any delay in writing so the record builds itself.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%Related