What it means
There are two quite different markets. Compliance markets are created by law, where regulators issue a limited number of allowances and firms covered by the scheme must surrender one for every tonne they emit, while voluntary markets let any organisation buy credits from projects such as reforestation or methane capture.
Quality varies enormously in the voluntary market, which is where most of the criticism lands. A credit is only meaningful if the reduction is additional, meaning it would not have happened anyway, and if it is permanent, verified independently and not sold twice.
For a business, the credit price acts as an internal price on carbon and makes abatement decisions arithmetically simple. If credits cost $85 a tonne and a factory upgrade cuts emissions at $75 a tonne, the upgrade is the cheaper route, and if the numbers reverse then buying credits is the rational short term choice.
Accounting treatment depends on the reason for holding them. Credits bought to settle a compliance obligation are generally treated as an intangible asset with a matching liability as emissions occur, while credits bought purely to be retired against a voluntary claim are usually expensed.
The commercial risk worth understanding is price volatility. Compliance allowance prices have swung widely as regulators tighten caps, so a business exposed to a scheme should treat carbon like any other input cost and consider hedging it rather than assuming today's price holds.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
A regional airline buys verified forestry credits to offset emissions from its domestic routes and markets the flights accordingly. Its sustainability team insists on credits from a recognised registry with independent verification, having rejected a cheaper supplier whose additionality claims did not stand up.
Example
A steel producer covered by a compliance scheme forecasts a shortfall of 60,000 allowances over three years. Rather than buying at spot prices each December, it purchases forward contracts to fix the cost and remove volatility from its budget.
Example
A dairy cooperative installs anaerobic digesters and finds the emissions reductions can themselves be registered and sold as credits. Revenue from the credits shortens the payback on the digesters from nine years to six.
Think of it
“Carbon credit is permission to emit carbon-a tradeable allowance for greenhouse gas emissions.
Formula
Calculation
Credits required = actual emissions in tonnes of CO2 equivalent - free allowances received, and cost of compliance = credits required x market price per credit
A cement producer emits 40,000 tonnes of CO2 equivalent in a year and receives 25,000 free allowances under its national scheme. It must buy 40,000 - 25,000 = 15,000 credits, and at $85 each that costs 15,000 x $85 = $1,275,000.
The company is considering a kiln heat recovery project costing $900,000 a year, which would cut emissions by 12,000 tonnes. That works out at $900,000 / 12,000 = $75 per tonne abated, below the $85 credit price.
With the project, emissions fall to 28,000 tonnes, so it buys only 15,000 - 12,000 = 3,000 credits at a cost of 3,000 x $85 = $255,000. Total spending becomes $900,000 + $255,000 = $1,155,000, which is $1,275,000 - $1,155,000 = $120,000 cheaper than buying credits alone, and the saving grows every year the credit price rises.Case study
Seen in the real world.
This is an illustrative, fictional example. Northgate Ceramics, an invented tile manufacturer, treated its annual allowance purchase as an unavoidable tax and budgeted roughly $1,300,000 a year for it without further thought.
A new engineering manager in this fictional account built a simple ranking of every possible reduction measure by cost per tonne abated. Waste heat recovery came out at $48 a tonne, kiln insulation at $71 and a switch of drying fuel at $132, against a prevailing credit price of $85.
Northgate funded the first two measures and kept buying credits for the rest, cutting its illustrative annual carbon cost by around $400,000 while reducing emissions by roughly a third. The fictional lesson is that a carbon price is not just a bill, it is a benchmark that tells you exactly which reduction projects are worth doing.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Assuming all credits are equivalent, when quality, verification standard and permanence vary so much that prices range from a few dollars to well over a hundred per tonne.
- Using offsets as a substitute for reducing emissions, which invites accusations of greenwashing and leaves the business exposed when regulators tighten the rules.
- Budgeting for carbon at last year's price, when compliance allowance prices have historically moved a long way in a single year.
Questions
People also ask.
What exactly does one carbon credit represent?
One tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent either avoided or removed, verified against a recognised methodology and recorded on a registry.
What is the difference between an allowance and an offset?
An allowance is a permit issued by a regulator under a capped scheme, while an offset is generated by a project that reduced or removed emissions outside such a scheme.
Where do carbon credits appear in the accounts?
Usually as an intangible asset when purchased, with a liability built up as emissions occur, and both are released when the credits are surrendered or retired.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%