What it means
Offsets fall into two broad families. Avoidance credits pay for something that stops emissions happening, such as replacing coal-fired power or preventing forest clearance, while removal credits pay for carbon to be taken out of the air and stored in trees, soil or geological formations.
Quality varies enormously, and price follows quality. Cheap credits from questionable projects have repeatedly failed independent scrutiny, so buyers now look at additionality, meaning the project would not have happened without the money, and permanence, meaning the carbon stays stored rather than being released by a fire or a change of land use.
The commercial mechanics are simple. You buy credits through a broker, an exchange or directly from a project developer, then retire them on a public registry so the same tonne cannot be sold twice, and the retirement record becomes your audit evidence.
In accounting terms most companies expense offsets in the period they relate to, treating them as an operating cost of doing business. Where credits are bought forward for future years, they are often carried as a prepayment or an intangible asset and released as they are retired.
The nuance worth remembering is that an offset never changes your own footprint. Your gross emissions stay exactly as measured; the offset only affects the net figure you disclose afterwards, which is why regulators are steadily tightening the language companies may use.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
An airline offers passengers an optional offset at checkout, priced at a few dollars per seat. Finance treats the collected amounts as a liability until the matching credits are retired, so the money cannot be recognised as revenue.
Example
A private equity-backed manufacturer buys three years of offsets in advance to fix its price ahead of an expected market tightening. The prepayment sits on the balance sheet and is released to the income statement as credits are retired each year.
Example
A retailer audits its offset portfolio and finds that a third of its credits come from a single avoidance project with weak baseline evidence. It writes those credits off, replaces them with higher-priced removal credits, and reports the change openly rather than waiting for a journalist to find it.
Think of it
“Carbon offset is paying to cancel out your emissions-funding reduction projects elsewhere.
Formula
Calculation
Offset cost = tonnes of CO2e to be offset x price per tonne.
Worked example. A packaged goods company has residual emissions of 12,000 tonnes of CO2e after its reduction projects, and buys credits at an average of $22 per tonne.
Offset cost = 12,000 x $22 = $264,000 for the year.
The company produced 400,000 units, so the cost per unit is 264,000 / 400,000 = $0.66.
Now test the sensitivity. If the average credit price rises to $30 per tonne, the cost becomes 12,000 x $30 = $360,000, an increase of $360,000 - $264,000 = $96,000. That $96,000 swing on an unchanged emissions volume is why buyers negotiate multi-year supply agreements rather than buying on the spot market every December.Case study
Seen in the real world.
This is an illustrative and entirely fictional example. Pinegate Logistics, an invented haulage operator, spent $180,000 a year on offsets so it could market carbon neutral delivery to its retail clients. The credits cost roughly $9 per tonne, which the operations director considered excellent value.
A client's sustainability team asked for the project documentation and found that most of the portfolio came from a forestry scheme with a shaky baseline. Pinegate replaced them with a mixed portfolio of higher-integrity avoidance and removal credits at an average of $27 per tonne, which pushed the bill to about $540,000.
Faced with a threefold increase, the board finally approved the fleet and route efficiency investment it had deferred twice. Emissions fell by roughly a quarter over two years, the offset bill came down with them, and the illustrative lesson stands: expensive offsets are the fastest way to make reduction projects look affordable.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Assuming all offsets are equivalent because they are all sold in tonnes, when project quality drives both price and reputational risk.
- Recording an offset purchase as a reduction in the company's own footprint, rather than as a separate line affecting only the net figure.
- Buying credits at the cheapest available price without checking additionality or permanence, then having to write them off when a client asks questions.
Questions
People also ask.
What does retiring a credit mean?
It means permanently cancelling it on a registry in your name so it cannot be sold or claimed again by anyone else.
Are offsets tax deductible?
In most jurisdictions they are treated as an ordinary business expense when incurred for commercial reasons, but the treatment of multi-year prepayments should be confirmed with your tax adviser.
How do I know a credit is genuine?
Look for issuance by a recognised registry, third-party verification, a clearly documented baseline and a public retirement record you can show an auditor.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%Related