What it means
The practice grew out of cheap online brokerage and low-cost index funds, which together removed most of the reasons a small investor needed an intermediary. A person can now build a globally diversified portfolio in a handful of clicks for a fraction of what a managed service would charge.
Cost is the central argument. Advice and active management commonly cost 1% to 2% of assets a year, and because that fee is charged on the whole balance rather than on the gain, it compounds against the investor for decades.
The trade-off is behavioural and administrative. Nobody talks a DIY investor out of selling at the bottom of a market fall, nobody notices when a portfolio has drifted badly out of balance, and nobody flags the tax consequence of a sale before it happens.
Most DIY investors settle on a simple structure: a small number of broad index funds held in a tax-sheltered account, rebalanced once or twice a year to fixed target weights. The discipline of a written plan matters more than the specific funds chosen, because it removes the need to make judgement calls under stress.
DIY is not all-or-nothing. Many people run a core DIY portfolio and pay for one-off advice on complex decisions such as pension consolidation, inheritance or business sale proceeds, which keeps the ongoing cost low while buying expertise where it genuinely earns its fee.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
A marketing director opens a low-cost brokerage account and puts her monthly savings into two index funds, one global equity and one bond. She rebalances every January and otherwise does nothing, and her total annual cost is under $200 on a six-figure balance.
Example
A restaurant owner tries DIY investing but finds himself checking prices daily and trading on news. After two years of underperforming a simple index, he moves to a low-cost managed portfolio, accepting the fee as the price of not interfering.
Example
A couple manage their retirement savings themselves but hire a financial planner for a flat fee when they inherit a property. The planner handles the tax and structuring questions, and the couple return to running the portfolio on their own afterwards.
Formula
Calculation
Annual cost of investing = Portfolio value x (Adviser fee % + Fund fee %) + Trading costs, and the long-run effect is measured by compounding the portfolio at the gross return minus the total cost.
An investor holds $250,000. Under an advised arrangement the adviser charges 1.00% and the underlying funds charge 0.30%, so the annual cost is 250,000 x 0.01 = $2,500 plus 250,000 x 0.003 = $750, a total of $3,250, or 1.30% a year. Running the same money in index funds charging 0.10% with commission-free trades costs 250,000 x 0.001 = $250 a year, saving $3,000 in year one alone. Projected over twenty years at a 6.0% gross return, the advised route compounds at 6.0% - 1.3% = 4.7% and grows to 250,000 x 1.047^20 = about $626,000, while the DIY route compounds at 6.0% - 0.1% = 5.9% and grows to 250,000 x 1.059^20 = about $787,000, a difference of roughly $161,000.Case study
Seen in the real world.
Marla Devane is an invented person in this illustrative scenario, a self-employed architect with $180,000 of savings who decided to stop paying a 1.1% advisory fee. She moved everything to an online broker, bought three index funds and wrote a one-page plan setting target weights and an annual rebalancing date.
The first two years went smoothly. In the third, a sharp market fall left her portfolio down 22% on paper, and she sold most of her equity fund over a single weekend, intending to buy back once things settled. Markets recovered within four months and she re-entered well above where she had sold.
The fictional arithmetic is uncomfortable: the fee saving over three years came to a few thousand dollars, while the round trip out of the market cost several times that. The illustrative point is that DIY investing saves a known cost and exposes the investor to an unknown one, and only a written plan followed without exception closes the gap.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Confusing DIY investing with active trading, when the approach that usually works is a small number of broad funds left alone for years.
- Focusing entirely on the adviser fee saved while ignoring the fund charges, platform fees and currency conversion costs that remain.
- Building a portfolio of ten overlapping funds in the belief it is diversified, when they often hold much the same underlying shares.
Questions
People also ask.
How much money do you need before DIY investing makes sense?
There is no minimum, though at very small balances flat platform fees can outweigh the percentage saving, so a low-cost or no-fee provider matters more than at larger sizes.
How often should a DIY portfolio be rebalanced?
Once or twice a year is generally enough, and rebalancing more often adds cost and tax events without improving results in a meaningful way.
Is DIY investing suitable for someone approaching retirement?
It can be, but the decisions get harder as drawdown, sequencing risk and tax interact, so many people who happily manage the accumulation phase pay for advice at that point.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%