What it means
Every asset sits somewhere on a spectrum running from cash to concrete. Money in a current account is instantly spendable, listed shares settle in a couple of days, a delivery van takes a few weeks, and a custom production line built for a discontinued product may take years or never sell at all.
What makes an asset hard to sell is rarely its quality. It is the combination of a small pool of buyers, high transaction costs, information gaps about condition or title, and the seller's own urgency, which buyers can sense and price into their offer.
This matters because lenders, insolvency practitioners and acquirers all discount these assets heavily. A bank lending against equipment will advance far less on specialised kit than on standard vehicles, because it is pricing what it could recover in a forced sale rather than what the asset is worth to you in normal use.
In practice the discount is applied in two layers: a haircut to the expected price, and a charge for the costs incurred while the asset waits for a buyer. Storage, insurance, security, maintenance and the finance cost of the capital tied up all keep running throughout the search.
A common variant is the asset that is not hard to sell in general but is hard to sell right now, because an entire sector is distressed at the same moment. Commercial property in a weak market and second-hand aircraft after a demand shock both behave this way, and the remedy is usually patience rather than price cutting.
Auditors look closely at these assets when testing whether carrying values are supported, and directors must consider them when judging whether the business can pay its debts as they fall due. An asset-rich, cash-poor company can still fail, because creditors want money rather than machinery.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
A regional brewery installs a bottling line configured for a bottle shape used by no other producer in the country. When it switches to cans, the line has a book value of $1,200,000 but attracts a single scrap offer, and the finance director records an impairment rather than carrying it at cost.
Example
A family holding company owns a 15% stake in an unlisted engineering firm with no shareholder agreement covering exit. When it needs cash for an inheritance tax bill, it finds no buyer will pay pro-rata value for a minority stake with no control and no dividend policy. The stake eventually sells to the majority owner at a substantial discount, 14 months after the process started.
Example
A property developer is left with a partially completed office block when its funding partner withdraws. Buyers price in the cost of completing the work, the risk of unknown defects and the planning consent expiry date. The developer accepts an offer well below cost, having spent nine months paying site security and business rates while waiting.
Formula
Calculation
The practical measure is net realisable proceeds, which strips out both the discount and the waiting cost:
Net proceeds = Expected sale price - Selling costs - Holding costs during the marketing period
A specialist ceramics kiln sits on the books at $800,000. The broker's view is that a realistic sale price is 30% below carrying value, so the expected price is $800,000 x 0.70 = $560,000, and that finding a buyer will take about 18 months.
Holding costs run at $12,000 a month for storage, insurance and maintenance, giving $12,000 x 18 = $216,000 across the marketing period. Broker commission is 5% of the sale price, or $560,000 x 0.05 = $28,000.
Net proceeds are therefore $560,000 - $216,000 - $28,000 = $316,000. That is $316,000 / $800,000 = 39.5% of carrying value, which explains why a lender might advance only a small fraction of book value against it.Case study
Seen in the real world.
Calder Ceramics is an invented company used here as an illustrative example of how these assets behave. It had spent $2,100,000 over three years on kilns, moulds and a bespoke glaze line to serve one large hotel-supply contract, and the equipment appeared on its balance sheet close to cost.
When the contract was not renewed, the board assumed it could sell the equipment and repay the asset finance facility. Instead the moulds proved worthless to anyone else, the glaze line needed a building with a very particular ceiling height, and the only serious enquiry came from a buyer offering a third of book value on condition that Calder paid for dismantling and transport.
The lesson the illustrative board drew was about the decision made three years earlier rather than the sale. Calder had funded single-customer equipment as though it were general-purpose plant, which meant its borrowing capacity was resting on assets that no second buyer wanted. Its revised policy set a lower internal recovery assumption for any asset bought to serve a single contract, and required that such purchases be paid down over the life of that contract rather than over the equipment's useful life.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Treating carrying value as sale value, when carrying value reflects cost less depreciation and says nothing about what a buyer would actually pay.
- Ignoring holding costs, which can quietly consume a large share of the proceeds when a sale takes a year or more.
- Counting hard-to-sell assets when assessing whether the business can meet short-term obligations, since liquidity ratios exist precisely to exclude them.
Questions
People also ask.
How big is the typical discount?
It varies widely, but specialised plant with a single realistic use commonly fetches somewhere between 20% and 50% of carrying value in an unhurried sale, and far less in a forced one.
Does an asset being hard to sell force an impairment?
Not automatically, because impairment tests compare carrying value with the higher of value in use and fair value less costs to sell, so an asset still earning well in the business can stay on the books at cost.
How can a business reduce the risk?
Prefer standard specifications where practical, match the repayment term of any finance to the contract the asset serves, and record a realistic recovery assumption at the point of purchase rather than at the point of sale.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%