What it means
Traditional and Roth IRAs receive separate treatment. Traditional distributions can include taxable amounts and recovery of previously taxed basis.
Roth treatment depends on the relevant qualification and ordering rules; the label Roth does not mean every possible withdrawal is unrestricted and tax-free. Basis records matter.
If a person made nondeductible traditional IRA contributions, not all distributed money is necessarily taxable. The applicable calculation and reporting must account for the records, rather than treating one account's withdrawal as entirely taxable or allowing the taxpayer to select only after-tax dollars informally.
Required minimum distributions are another topic. The publication explains when withdrawals must occur and how applicable amounts are calculated.
Owner and beneficiary rules differ, so a familiar withdrawal routine should not be copied automatically after an account owner's death. Inherited accounts require specific facts.
The relationship to the deceased owner, beneficiary category, date of death, and other circumstances can affect the available treatment. A surviving spouse's alternatives should not be assumed to apply identically to every other beneficiary.
An additional tax on an early distribution is separate from ordinary income tax. An exception can remove the additional tax without necessarily making the distribution itself tax-free.
A person should distinguish those questions before using an exception as a reason to budget the whole payment for spending. The live edition is labelled for preparing 2025 returns and refers readers to current updates, so keep tax-year labels with copied tables and check later changes rather than using an old age threshold or divisor from memory.
The 2025 edition says SEP and SIMPLE plans are covered in Publication 560, so this document is not a complete guide to those arrangements. For record preparation, identify the exact IRA type and collect statements, distribution records, and basis information before choosing a worksheet.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
A fictional retiree takes money from a traditional IRA containing nondeductible contributions. His preparer asks for historic basis records and the relevant forms. The fact that the custodian sent cash does not settle how much is taxable, and the preparer does not assume basis belongs only to the account selected for withdrawal.
Example
A beneficiary inherits an IRA and copies a friend's annual withdrawal calculation. The adviser first checks the relationship, death year, and beneficiary classification. An inherited-account rule is not established by a friend's experience or by the beneficiary's age alone.
Example
A saver learns that a qualifying distribution can escape an early-withdrawal additional tax. She separately asks whether ordinary income tax remains. The two questions affect the money actually available for her expense, even when the same payment appears in both calculations.
Formula
Calculation
A simplified required-distribution illustration uses prior year-end account value divided by an applicable distribution period. Selecting the correct table and divisor requires the account and taxpayer facts; the example below does not supply that selection.
Suppose an adviser has established an applicable divisor of 25.0 and the relevant balance is $150,000. The illustrative amount is $150,000 / 25.0 = $6,000. If only $4,500 qualifying distributions have been taken, the remaining amount under these assumptions is $1,500.
A second simplified illustration concerns basis. If a fictional owner has $20,000 of nondeductible contributions, a year-end balance of $90,000 and takes a $10,000 distribution, the pro-rata fraction is $20,000 / ($90,000 + $10,000) = 20%. Under these assumptions $2,000 of the distribution is a return of basis and $8,000 is taxable, again subject to the actual rules and forms.
Tax treatment and deadlines still require the actual rules.Case study
Seen in the real world.
In this fictional case, Calder Design's retired founder asks the office manager to organise IRA records for an adviser. The file includes a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA, inherited-account correspondence, and several years of distribution statements. The manager initially places every withdrawal in one spreadsheet column. She revises the file to identify account type, owner or beneficiary status, tax year, and relevant basis records. The adviser then selects the appropriate Publication 590-B sections and any additional guidance.
The organised file helps avoid using one calculation for different arrangements, while the manager leaves tax conclusions and withdrawal decisions to the properly informed review. The founder later asks whether the same spreadsheet can be reused next year. The manager keeps the structure but starts a new tab for each tax year and records the source of every figure. That makes it easier for the adviser to see which numbers came from custodian statements and which were estimates, and it keeps old figures from drifting into a new year's analysis.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Assuming an exception to an early-distribution additional tax also removes ordinary income tax from the payment.
- Applying an original owner's withdrawal rules to every inherited IRA without checking beneficiary classification and the relevant dates.
- Selecting a distribution table or tax-year figure from memory and overlooking basis records, updated rules, or guidance for a different retirement arrangement.
Questions
People also ask.
Is Publication 590-B mainly about contributions?
No. It principally addresses distributions. Publication 590-A covers contributions and related matters, while other publications address specific employer arrangements.
Does every traditional IRA withdrawal face tax on the entire amount?
Not necessarily. Previously taxed basis and other relevant rules can affect the taxable amount. The calculation needs accurate records and applicable reporting instructions.
Can an inherited Roth IRA require withdrawals?
Yes. The original owner's treatment and a beneficiary's distribution requirements differ. Check the inherited-account rules instead of assuming the account can remain untouched indefinitely.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%