What it means
A utility bill arrives after month-end for services already received, so an accountant may post an accrual with an expense debit and liability credit, link it to the estimate, and reverse or settle it as the process requires. Oracle's general-ledger documentation describes journal headers, debit and credit lines, attachments and reversal settings, but software fields help an audit trail without determining whether an accounting judgment is right.
The PCAOB's journal-entry audit focus discusses testing entries as part of addressing fraud risk, which does not mean every manual journal is fraudulent, only that appropriate controls are needed. Distinguish source from purpose: a manual journal can be perfectly valid, though direct entries may bypass ordinary invoice or sales workflows, which is the higher concern.
Set a unique journal ID, date and legal entity, because a posting to the wrong company or period can distort results even if total debits equal credits. Describe the reason plainly, since "Correction" does not explain which earlier entry was wrong, and reference the original transaction and the basis for the new treatment.
Attach support such as a calculation, contract, invoice, reconciliation or approved estimate that matches the amounts posted, because reviewers need the underlying evidence and not only a comment field. Check account codes, since a debit to an expense instead of an asset can change profit despite a balanced credit, and consider tax and reporting dimensions where relevant.
Balance debits and credits: an illustrative journal of a $1,000 debit to expense and a $1,000 credit to accrued liability is balanced, with net debit minus credit of zero while expense and liability both rise by $1,000, but balance alone does not prove the amount belongs in that period. Avoid duplicate entries by searching related accounts, references and prior journals, because another team may have already booked the supplier invoice or the same accrual.
Plan reversals, since some accruals are automatically reversed next period while others remain until settlement, and a wrong reversal date can create an unexpected swing. Define review, with independent approval, sensible thresholds and exception handling for higher-risk entries, and compensating oversight where a person posts and approves their own sensitive entry.
Protect permissions by limiting who may post directly to the ledger and logging privileged changes so that system access aligns with job responsibilities, and watch late entries, because a journal posted after reports are drafted may require refreshed reconciliations and disclosures and closing checklists should track final versions. Separate preparation from posting where the system allows, since a draft can be returned for correction before it affects reports, while a posted entry usually needs an adjusting trail.
Classify recurring journals, because reusing last month as a template can save time but amounts, dates and assumptions should be refreshed instead of copied blindly. Reconcile accounts after posting, since bank, receivable and other balance reviews can detect mistakes not obvious in individual journals, and maintain a correction trail by reversing or adjusting an erroneous entry according to policy rather than deleting history, explaining what changed and why.
Consider currency, because a journal in a foreign currency may use conversion rates and create exchange differences, so transaction and reporting currencies should be stated correctly, and review unusual patterns such as round values, weekend posting, unusual account combinations and entries near period close, which may merit attention although none alone proves misconduct. For owners, manual journals are necessary tools for accounting judgments and repairs, and their trustworthiness comes from specific support, controlled access and review.
In practice
Real-world examples.
Example
An accountant records a $1,440 accrued utility expense at month-end, attaching the meter reading and the supplier's tariff as support. The entry is dated to the correct period and reverses automatically on the first day of the next month. The reviewer checks the amount against last year's bills before approving.
Example
A mistaken account code is corrected with a linked adjusting journal. An $8,000 equipment purchase was booked to repairs expense, so the accountant debits Equipment $8,000 and credits Repairs expense $8,000, referencing the original entry. The original stays visible, so the audit trail shows what was wrong and when it was fixed.
Example
A recurring allocation of $12,000 a month of shared costs between two departments is entered manually and reviewed against its calculation. The preparer refreshes the headcount driver each month rather than copying last month's split. The reviewer checks that the two departmental shares still add to $12,000.
Formula
Calculation
Accrual = estimated cost of services received but not yet invoiced. Journal: debit expense, credit accrued liability, for the same amount. Total debits must equal total credits, but accounting validity still needs evidence.
Worked example. At 31 March a business has used electricity but the bill has not arrived, and the supporting estimate is $1,440. The accrual journal is debit Utilities expense $1,440 and credit Accrued liabilities $1,440, so total debits of $1,440 equal total credits of $1,440. On 1 April the accrual is reversed with a debit to Accrued liabilities of $1,440 and a credit to Utilities expense of $1,440. When the invoice arrives for $1,500, the business debits Utilities expense $1,500 and credits Accounts payable $1,500. March carries $1,440 of expense and April carries $1,500 - $1,440 = $60, so the two months total the true cost of $1,500.
If the reversal is forgotten, the expense would be $1,440 + $1,500 = $2,940, which overstates cost by $1,440.Case study
Seen in the real world.
This entirely fictional example follows Vale Services. It booked a year-end accrual of $48,000 manually, but the same invoice was later posted through the normal payables workflow without the accrual being reversed. Expense was therefore recorded twice, $96,000 against a true cost of $48,000, which overstated cost by $48,000.
The team linked accrual IDs to invoice processing and reviewed open reversals each month. It retained the original and correcting records so the history stayed visible. The case does not imply all manual journals are unreliable.
Watch out
Common mistakes.
- Assuming balanced debits and credits mean the journal is substantively correct.
- Posting a correction without linking the original entry or supporting evidence.
- Forgetting a planned reversal and duplicating an expense when the invoice arrives.
Questions
People also ask.
What is a manual journal?
An entry prepared or keyed by a person directly for the general ledger.
Are manual journals always inappropriate?
No. Accruals, allocations and corrections can need manual entries.
What support should accompany one?
A reason, proper accounts and period, supporting evidence and suitable approval.
From the founder's library
Take it further with the book.
Build your financial confidence beyond this definition. Shihan's full-length guide, Accounting Fundamentals, takes the same plain-English approach and turns it into a complete, practical playbook for non-finance managers, business owners and students - with chapter-end quiz answers and presentation slides included.
25% off with code MMHQ25, applied at checkout. Priced in USD - checkout may show the equivalent in your local currency.
View the book and save 25%