This term
What it means
When executives hold significant equity in their own organisation, outright sales can trigger negative market sentiment and heavy tax charges. These contracts provide a practical alternative for accessing cash without immediate disposal, though they require careful structuring to manage regulatory scrutiny.
Beyond corporate finance, they highlight the tension between personal liquidity needs and long-term governance expectations. The shareholder enters an agreement with a bank, receives a payment today that is a high percentage of the current share value, and pledges the shares as security.
At maturity, usually in a few years, the shareholder delivers a number of shares set by a formula that depends on the price on that date. The formula sets a floor price and a cap price.
If the share price ends at or below the floor, the shareholder delivers all the shares, and the bank bears the fall below the floor, while if the price lands between the floor and the cap, the shareholder delivers fewer shares and keeps the rest. Above the cap, the shareholder gives up further gains because the number of shares delivered rises again.
The structure is, in effect, a collar (a combination of a bought put option and a sold call option) combined with a loan. The shareholder can also usually settle in cash instead of delivering shares.
Tax treatment is the point of controversy. Many arrangements are designed so that the shareholder is not treated as having sold the shares until delivery, and tax authorities look closely at whether the substance of the deal is a sale.
The rules differ between countries and have changed over time, so specialist advice is essential. For a company, such arrangements raise governance questions.
Boards often require disclosure and approval when executives use them, since hedging can reduce the alignment between an executive's interests and the interests of other shareholders.
In practice
Real-world examples
Example 1
A founder owns 2 million shares in a listed technology company and wants cash for a property purchase. She enters a variable prepaid forward with a bank and receives 80% of the value up front. She delivers shares in three years' time under the formula.
Example 2
A senior executive worries that the share price might fall before he can sell under company rules. He agrees a floor at today's price, which protects him from a fall. In return, he gives up gains above the cap.
Example 3
A bank evaluates a request from a client with a large concentrated holding. It checks the liquidity of the shares, sets the floor and cap, and decides how much cash to advance. It charges a financing cost that is built into the terms.
Formula
Shares delivered at maturity, with N shares pledged, floor price F, cap price C and share price P at maturity
Note
If P is at or below F, shares delivered = N
If P is above F and at or below C, shares delivered = N x F / P
If P is above C, shares delivered = N x (P - C + F) / P
An executive pledges 100,000 shares worth $50 each, which is $5,000,000.
The floor is $50 and the cap is $70, and she receives an upfront payment of $4,000,000, which is 80% of the value.
At maturity the share price is $62.50, between the floor and the cap, so shares delivered = 100,000 x 50 / 62.50 = 80,000
The delivered shares are worth:
80,000 x 62.50 = $5,000,000
She keeps the other 20,000 shares, worth:
20,000 x 62.50 = $1,250,000
Plus the $4,000,000 she received earlier.
If the price had been $80, above the cap, she would deliver:
100,000 x (80 - 70 + 50) / 80 = 75,000 shares
Case study
Seen in the real world
This illustrative story is about a fictional executive, Daniel, who held 500,000 shares of a fictional company, Brightfield Technologies, worth $40 each. Almost all of his wealth was tied to one share price, and the company's results were uncertain.
He entered a variable prepaid forward through a fictional bank, with a floor of $40 and a cap of $56, and took an upfront payment of $16,000,000, which is 80% of the $20,000,000 value. The company's share price fell to $30 by maturity, below the floor, so he delivered all 500,000 shares and kept the $16,000,000 as settlement.
Without the contract, Daniel's shares would have been worth $15,000,000. The structure gave him the cash he needed and protected him against the fall, but if the price had risen to $56 or more he would have given up the gains above the cap. The story is fictional, but it shows the trade-off in the design.
Watch out
Common mistakes
- Treating the upfront payment as free money. It is a financing arrangement with a cost built in, and the shares remain pledged until maturity.
- Assuming there is no tax risk. Tax authorities may challenge the treatment, and the position depends on the exact terms and the local rules.
- Forgetting disclosure rules. Executives and directors may need company approval and public disclosure before entering such a contract.
Questions
People also ask
Is a variable prepaid forward the same as a loan?
It works like a loan in cash flow terms, but legally it is a forward sale of a variable number of shares, which is why tax treatment is so important.
What does variable mean here?
The number of shares to be delivered varies with the share price at maturity, between the floor and the cap.
Can the holder keep the shares by settling in cash?
Often yes, many contracts allow cash settlement or share settlement, at the holder's choice, subject to the terms.